Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau stirred controversy after posting — and quickly deleting — a remark questioning NATO’s relevance. The now-removed post on X came in response to U.S. Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker, who had emphasized the Indo-Pacific's importance to transatlantic security. Landau replied, “NATO is still a solution in search of a problem,” referencing a recent Deputies Committee meeting.
The State Department clarified that Landau’s comment was meant as a “lighthearted” and “private” exchange. A spokesperson later said the remark reflected Landau’s intent to strengthen NATO and ensure mission focus. The Deputies Committee is part of the National Security Council structure, consisting of top-level officials from State, Defense, and other agencies.
Landau’s statement stands in contrast to the majority view among NATO’s European members, who regard Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine as a core threat and NATO as central to regional defense. It also diverges from President Joe Biden’s policy of encouraging European allies to engage more with Indo-Pacific challenges, especially those related to China.
The controversy comes just ahead of NATO’s two-day summit in The Hague, beginning June 24. The summit will likely be dominated by discussions around former President Donald Trump’s demand for members to increase defense spending to 5% of GDP. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy is expected to attend, continuing his active engagement with NATO since Russia’s invasion in February 2022.
Trump’s softened stance toward Moscow and criticisms of NATO have unsettled European allies, raising doubts about continued U.S. commitment to the 32-member alliance and its unified support for Ukraine’s defense.